What a CCRC Entrance Fee Actually Buys in Western New York

A six-figure check to a life plan community is the largest single decision most Buffalo-area families make about senior care — and New York regulates it more like an insurance product than a lease. Here is what Public Health Law Article 46 actually requires, and what the contract does and does not promise.

By the Buffalo Senior Advisor Care Team · October 23, 2026

“Continuing Care Retirement Community” Is a License, Not a Brochure Word

Families touring Western New York campuses hear the phrase “continuum of care” constantly, and reasonably assume it means the same thing everywhere. In New York it does not. Continuing Care Retirement Community is a specific licensure category created by Public Health Law Article 46, and § 4604(1) is blunt about it: no one may construct, operate, enter into a contract as an operator, solicit contracts, “or advertise itself or otherwise hold itself as a ‘continuing care retirement community’” without first obtaining a certificate of authority.

That certificate is not a routine filing. Under § 4601(1) it is approved by the Continuing Care Retirement Community Council and issued by the Commissioner of Health. The Council, established by § 4603(1), is made up of the Attorney General, the Commissioner of Health, the Director of the Office for the Aging, and eight public members appointed by the governor — at least two of whom must themselves live in a CCRC. Before a certificate issues, § 4604(4)(a) also requires sign-off from the Superintendent of Financial Services on the actuarial principles involved, the financial feasibility of the facility, and the form and content of the proposed contracts.

In other words, New York treats a CCRC entrance fee as a long-dated financial promise that has to be priced and reserved for, not simply a move-in cost. That is why the regulatory machinery looks so different from the adult home and assisted living rules covered in our New York state rules guide.

The Western New York Communities on the State's List

The Department of Health publishes the roster of communities holding a CCRC Certificate of Authority. At the time of writing the statewide list runs to roughly a dozen communities, and the Western New York entries are Canterbury Woods and Fox Run at Orchard Park. Canterbury Woods, on 62 acres at 705 Renaissance Drive in Williamsville, describes itself as Western New York's first CCRC and is operated by Episcopal Church Home & Affiliates, the same nonprofit behind Canterbury Woods Gates Circle in Buffalo's Elmwood Village. Fox Run, at 1 Fox Run Lane in Orchard Park, markets itself as a full-continuum Life Care community and publishes July 2026 CMS Five-Star ratings of 5 stars overall, 5 for health inspections, 4 for quality measures, and 5 for staffing on its skilled nursing side.

A caution worth taking seriously: a certificate belongs to an operator and a defined community, and sister campuses under one nonprofit parent are not automatically covered by the same certificate. Ask the Department directly, at [email protected], which campuses a given certificate covers before you assume the Article 46 protections below apply to the building you toured.

Just as important is what the list does not include. The GreenFields, the 52-acre Niagara Lutheran Health System campus in Lancaster, Asbury Pointe in Getzville, and Presbyterian Village at North Church in Williamsville all offer genuine continuity under a single nonprofit, and all are worth touring. They are licensed building by building — independent living, adult home or assisted living residence, skilled nursing — rather than as Article 46 CCRCs. That is not a quality judgment. It is a contract difference: no Article 46 entrance fee, no Article 46 escrow, no Article 46 refund schedule, and no guaranteed on-campus nursing benefit baked into what you sign. For families weighing single-campus continuity against assembling their own providers, our Orchard Park comparison works through that trade-off in one town.

Where the Money Sits Before You Move In

The protection most families do not know they have is § 4610, New York's escrow requirement. As a condition of being allowed to advertise and collect refundable entrance fees or deposits, an operator must establish an interest-bearing account at a New York bank, savings and loan association, or trust company. Section 4610(3) requires that checks be made payable to the escrow agent only — not to the community. Section 4610(4) is the sentence to remember: all funds deposited in the escrow account remain the property of the resident until released to the operator.

Release is not at the operator's discretion. Under § 4610(6)(a) the money can generally go to the community only once construction or purchase is substantially complete, an occupancy permit covering the living unit has been issued, and the unit is actually available to move into; § 4610(6)(b) sets separate, capped conditions for drawing on escrow as construction financing. If the project never gets there, § 4610(7) requires the escrow agent to return the unreleased funds to the people who paid them. And a community cannot break ground on speculation: § 4610(10) blocks construction until contracts are in hand carrying deposits of at least ten percent of the entry fee on fifty percent of all units, a threshold the Department of Health describes in plain terms as a fifty percent pre-sale requirement.

There is also a short, absolute cooling-off window. Section 4610(11) makes an entry fee deposit fully refundable if the contract is cancelled within seventy-two hours of its execution, with the refund due within three business days of the cancellation notice. Seventy-two hours is not long. If a tour ends with a signing table, that clock is the reason to go home and read first.

Type A, Type B, and Fee-for-Service: What You Are Actually Buying

The entrance fee buys a promise about future care, and the size of that promise varies enormously by contract type. The Department of Health describes the Article 46 options as life care (Type A) and modified (Type B).

A life care contract is defined at § 4601(8) as a contract to provide a person, for the duration of that person's life, the services of the community — and those services “shall include unlimited services of the affiliated community's nursing facility.” That is the strongest version: the community absorbs the cost risk of a long nursing-home stay. A modified contract includes a defined nursing benefit rather than an unlimited one. Underneath both sits a statutory floor. Section 4601(2-b)(b) requires a CCRC to provide at minimum sixty days of prepaid nursing facility services for residents not on a fee-for-service contract, and § 4601(2-b)(d) states that nothing in Article 46 eliminates that obligation. Those first sixty days are the days not covered by Medicare — which is a different benefit with its own rules, walked through in our guide to Medicare's 100 skilled nursing days.

New York also runs a separate track, Article 46-A, titled the Fee-for-Service Continuing Care Retirement Communities Demonstration Program. Section 4651(9) defines its contract as one providing long-term care and other services “on a per diem, fee-for-service or other agreed upon rate.” The Department of Health puts the consequence plainly: there is no long-term care benefit included in the contract, and the resident pays for long-term care if and when it is needed. A fee-for-service community can still charge an entrance fee — § 4651(6) contemplates one — so an entrance fee by itself tells you nothing about whether future nursing care is covered. The Department's published list identifies the demonstration-program community as Good Shepherd Village at Endwell in Broome County, not a Western New York location.

How Refunds Actually Work

Section 4608(5) of the contract rules requires every CCRC contract to spell out the terms under which it may be cancelled and the conditions under which all or part of the entrance fee is refunded. The Department of Health describes the statutory minimum as the traditional declining contract: the refund is reduced by two percent per month, with a one-time four percent processing fee, reaching zero after forty-eight months of residency. Several New York communities also offer ninety percent or fifty percent refundable contracts, generally in exchange for a substantially higher entrance fee.

Run that arithmetic before you choose. A declining contract is cheaper up front and leaves nothing to an estate after four years. A ninety percent refundable contract costs more and functions closer to a returnable deposit for heirs. Neither is correct in the abstract; the right answer turns on the resident's age and health, whether there is a spouse at home, and what the family expects to need the money for later.

Two further protections are worth knowing. Under § 4608(7), if a resident dies before occupancy or is otherwise precluded from becoming a resident, the contract is automatically rescinded and all money paid is refunded, less costs incurred at the resident's written request. And § 4608(17) prohibits substituting property as payment for either the entrance fee or the monthly fee — the house cannot simply be signed over in place of cash.

The Disclosure Packet You Are Legally Owed

Section 4606 requires the operator to deliver its most recent annual statement and an initial disclosure statement before the contract is executed or before any money changes hands — other than a refundable priority reservation fee or a non-refundable application fee — whichever comes first. The disclosure must include the contract itself, all fees including entrance fees, the identity of the provider and manager, rate changes over the previous five years, parent-company information, and a certified financial statement. Item 13 specifically requires a description of the contracted services “including, but not limited to, any limitations on nursing facility services.” Item 14 requires a standard information sheet in plain language and twelve point type, distributed with marketing materials, listing all fees, charges, and refund options.

Section 4604(8) requires both the disclosure statement and the contract to carry a notice in bold twelve point print on the cover stating that the matter “involves a substantial financial investment and a legally binding contract” and recommending that the reader consult an attorney and financial advisor of their own choosing. The same section obliges the operator to make knowledgeable personnel available to answer questions about it. New York put that warning in statute for a reason. Treat it as an instruction rather than boilerplate.

Ongoing costs are regulated too. Section 4608(10) requires at least sixty days' advance notice of any change in fees, charges, or scope of care or services, and § 4608(16) requires the Superintendent of Financial Services to approve amendments and fee increases that fall outside an approved rating methodology.

What a CCRC Contract Does Not Do

It does not make a family Medicaid-proof. A life care contract transfers the cost risk of nursing care onto the community, but it is a private purchase made with private assets — not a public benefit, and not a substitute for planning. If assets run short, if there is a spouse remaining in the community, or if estate recovery is a concern, those questions need a New York elder-law attorney, not a sales office. Our walkthrough of New York's nursing-home Medicaid spend-down covers the shape of that separate problem.

It also is not automatically the cheapest path. For scale, CareScout's 2024 Cost of Care Survey puts the New York state median at roughly $6,300 a month for assisted living and about $14,722 a month for a semi-private nursing home room. Those are statewide medians, weighted heavily by downstate pricing; CareScout does not publish a Buffalo-metro figure, and no published memory-care median exists for New York at all. The honest comparison is a specific community's quoted entrance fee and monthly fee against a realistic projection of what the same person would spend paying month to month — the arithmetic laid out in our cost break-even guide and on our cost of care page.

One more option exists on paper. Section 4601(8-b) defines a continuing care at home contract, which coordinates long-term care services in a person's own home through a case manager, with access to the community's nursing and adult care facilities. Section 4601(2-b)(f) requires any community offering such contracts to also offer standard CCRC contracts and to maintain a campus supporting them. These programs are not common in New York; ask directly rather than assuming one is available locally.

Questions to Ask Before You Sign

Ask whether the community holds a CCRC Certificate of Authority and which campuses it covers, then verify with the Department rather than with the brochure. Ask whether the contract is Type A life care, Type B modified, or fee-for-service, and what happens in year six of a nursing stay under each. Ask for the refund schedule in writing and the specific month at which the refund reaches zero. Ask for the five-year history of rate increases that § 4606 already requires be disclosed. Ask what happens if a resident outlives their assets, and get the answer in the contract rather than in conversation. Ask where the escrow account is held and in whose name.

And use the free help that exists before you need it. NY Connects in Erie County, at (716) 858-8526, is the state's no-wrong-door information service; the Region 15 Long Term Care Ombudsman Program at People Inc., (716) 817-9222, is the independent advocate for residents across Erie, Niagara, Cattaraugus, and Chautauqua counties once someone has moved in. For the skilled nursing side of any campus you are considering, cross-check the current federal rating at medicare.gov/care-compare, and check adult care facility inspection history at profiles.health.ny.gov/acf.

Statute sections cited here were read from New York's published Public Health Law and the Department of Health's CCRC program page. They change, and the Department's own published community list carries internal inconsistencies in its count. Confirm anything you intend to rely on financially with the Department of Health, the Department of Financial Services, or your own attorney before you write a check.

Common Questions